Proton X50 or MG MG HS? Comprehensive Malaysian Car Review Analysis

In the Malaysian SUV market, many buyers compare the Proton X50 and the MG MG HS when choosing a car. These two models are quite close in price and positioning. Today, we will make a detailed comparison from multiple aspects to save you time on research.

Price and Versions

The OTR price of the Proton X50 in Malaysia is RM 89,800 - 113,300, with a total of 4 versions, including 1.5T Executive (RM 89,800), 1.5T Premium (RM 101,800), 1.5T Flagship (RM 113,300), etc.

The OTR price of the MG MG HS in Malaysia is RM 130,450 - 146,450, with a total of 2 versions, including 1.5L Standard (RM 105,000), 1.5L Executive (RM 115,000), etc.

From the price perspective, the starting price of the Proton X50 is indeed RM 40,650 cheaper than the MG MG HS. If your budget is limited, the entry-level version of Proton can already meet daily needs. However, keep in mind that the few thousand difference might involve trade-offs in equipment, depending on your specific needs.

Power and Fuel Consumption

The Proton X50 is equipped with a 1.5L 4-cyl engine, 105 hp. Official fuel consumption 6.0 L/100km.

The MG MG HS is equipped with a 1.5L Turbo engine, 140 hp. Official fuel consumption 7.0 L/100km.

In terms of power, the MG MG HS's 1.5L Turbo has 35 more horsepower than the Proton X50's 1.5L 4-cyl. However, for daily city driving, both cars have sufficient power and won't feel underpowered.

Space and Comfort

The Proton X50 body length is 4400 mm, trunk 400 L.

The MG MG HS body length is 4400 mm, trunk 400 L.

The dimensions of both cars are almost the same, and the interior space difference is not significant. For this class of car, it is completely sufficient for daily use.

Features and Technology

The Proton X50 adopts a 4WD drive system.

The MG MG HS adopts an FWD drive system.

The Proton 4WD and MG FWD will feel different in handling, it is recommended to test drive and compare.

Maintenance and Warranty

The Proton X50 warranty is 5 years/150,000km, service interval every 10,000km or 6 months.

The MG MG HS warranty is 7 years/150,000km, service interval every 10,000km or 6 months.

Conclusion

In general, the Proton X50 and MG MG HS are both very good models in the Malaysian market. Which one to choose depends mainly on your personal needs and budget. We recommend doing your research, comparing quotes from multiple car dealers, and then test driving to make a final decision. Buying a car is a big matter, spending some time doing research is never wrong.