Around October 30, eight leading automakers sequentially submitted their Q3 earnings reports.
We spread these eight reports on the screen, flipping through them for nearly an hour. The more we looked, the more things felt off. Submitted within two days, same selling cars in China, same rushing onto the new energy train, yet the numbers differ like answer sheets from two parallel worlds.
On one side, BYD's Q3 single-quarter revenue was 221.488 billion, net profit attributable to parents 10.02 billion, up 28.08% YoY. Geely single-quarter revenue 99 billion, core profit 5.21 billion, up 32%. Chery gross profit for the first three quarters 39.004 billion, up more than 30%.
On the other side, GAC lost 2.52 billion in Q3, cumulative loss 6.987 billion in the first three quarters, gross margin dropped to negative 0.96%. Equivalent to costing 100,000 to build a car, selling it but not even recouping 100,000. Changan single quarter lost 758 million, turned from profit to loss.
Seres showed a single quarter profit of 1.42 billion on books, but after deducting money unrelated to selling cars like asset sales and government subsidies, the main business actually lost 1.365 billion. SAIC single quarter net profit was only 486 million, down 76.7% YoY; Great Wall first three quarters net profit 3.826 billion, halved YoY.
Seeing this, most people would throw out the universal phrase "industry pressure, too competitive".
True, but it explains nothing. Pressure is borne by everyone together, competitiveness is shared by everyone together. Why do some make money on every car sold while others lose money on every car?
The Same Car, Two Books of Accounts
After flipping through these eight reports carefully N times, I slowly understood one thing: the line that truly splits automakers in half is not in the domestic price war, nor in whose smart driving is smarter or whose battery is cheaper. It hides in a table that most people skip over at a glance — overseas sales volume.

[Table by Mala Che Shi]
To clarify this gap, we must first put the accounts side by side.
These three profit-making companies share one common point: sales growth isn't necessarily the fastest, but profit growth leads revenue, and revenue growth leads sales growth.
BYD sold 3.1316 million vehicles in the first three quarters, down 3.94% YoY. Domestic Q3 sales even dropped 12%, yet net profit actually rose 28%.
Geely sold 2.2355 million vehicles in the first three quarters, breaking a new record against the backdrop of a 6% overall decline in the domestic passenger car industry. Core net profit per vehicle was 6,664 yuan, up 37% from last year.
Chery sold 2.0769 million vehicles in the first three quarters. Gross profit rose 32%, nearly 20 percentage points faster than revenue growth.
This isn't achieved by saving money. BYD spent 36.277 billion on R&D in the first three quarters, 13.9 billion more than its 22.345 billion net profit attributable to parents in the same period. Chery R&D expenditure 11.046 billion, up 40%, three times the revenue growth rate.
They didn't shy away from price wars either. In Q2, BYD average vehicle price dropped from about 160,000 last quarter to about 136,000. In the most competitive 100,000 to 150,000 segment, they fought toe-to-toe there.
Where did the money come from? The answer is four words: overseas premium.
First half of this year, BYD overseas operating revenue 181.268 billion, for the first time in history surpassing domestic, accounting for 52.57% of total revenue. More crucially, the profit margin: overseas business gross margin 21.71%, domestic only 15.67%. A securities firm calculated, BYD overseas profit per vehicle is about 16,000 yuan, domestic only 2,000 yuan. Same R&D, same supply chain, same Blade Battery, change a market and re-price, profit multiplies several times over.
Geely exported 797,700 vehicles in the first three quarters, up 169% YoY. Among them, new energy exports 484,000, up 531%. It also set a mid-term goal for overseas business: 600,000 for Pan-Europe, 500,000 for ASEAN, 400,000 for Latin America & Africa in 2028.
Chery is even tougher, exported 1.4991 million vehicles in the first three quarters, accounting for over 70% of total sales. Overseas profit per vehicle is clearly better than domestic. Chery executives said a big truth at the performance meeting: selling a bottle of mineral water still earns 15 cents, some automakers still lose money selling a car.
The other half not spoken might be: Chery's domestic new energy business is currently in the investment phase. What is truly making money is that overseas 70% of sales.
Gone Overseas, Why Still No Profit
Seeing this you might think: Just go overseas then? Not that simple. SAIC and Great Wall are two ready-made counterexamples.
SAIC exported and overseas base sales 1.1656 million in the first three quarters, up 52.36% YoY. MG sold 280,000 in Europe in the first three quarters, 18,000 in the UK in September alone, setting a brand record.
But its first three quarters revenue 455.22 billion, down 2.9%, net profit only 5.64 billion, down 30.4%; Q3 net profit 486 million, down 76.7%.
Great Wall first three quarters overseas sales 476,000, up 42.43%, accounting for 51.7% of its 920,300 total sales, for the first time over half; domestic sales dropped 24%. Sold more overseas than domestic, but first three quarters net profit halved YoY.
Cars were sold, money wasn't earned. Where is the problem?
Great Wall itself gave three reasons in the financial report: continuous domestic market pressure, delayed recovery of overseas tax policy subsidy returns, exchange rate fluctuations.
On the SAIC side, financial expenses turned from net income 1.142 billion in the same period last year to net expenditure 4.052 billion, mainly due to exchange rates. Simply put, cars were sold, but subsidies that should have arrived are stuck on the road, and foreign exchange earned is bitten away by exchange rates after changing hands.
Add tariffs. The EU imposed anti-subsidy duties on Chinese EVs. SAIC took the highest tier 35.3%, stacked on top of 10% base import tax, comprehensive tax burden as high as 45.3%. BYD is 17%, Geely is 18.8%. In other words, for every car SAIC sells to Europe, it first has to hand over nearly half as tax.
Chery also suffered this loss. It recorded net exchange loss of 3.171 billion in the first three quarters, while the same period last year was exchange gain 2.974 billion, a difference of over 6.1 billion going back and forth. Excluding this one-time gain/loss, its core profit should have been over 17 billion.
This is why some go overseas and make a fortune, while others just create a stir.
SAIC and Great Wall still do the old way: make good cars in China, load on ships, find local dealers to sell. The profit on this road naturally has to pass through exchange rates and tariffs, one harder than the other. While BYD, Geely, Chery in recent years are doing another thing: moving factories, channels, R&D, procurement together to others' doorsteps.
BYD has already built complete vehicle bases in Thailand, Brazil, Indonesia. The Szeged factory in Hungary is planned to start production in Q4 this year, its first passenger car base in Europe. Local parts procurement ratio in Rayong factory, Thailand is already about 50%. Brazil Camaçari factory Phase 1 150,000 units, expanded to 300,000 by year-end.
BYD Li Ke said something in Singapore in October, more illustrative than any sales figure: promote local production and local procurement, from a global enterprise to become local enterprises rooted around the world.
Geely's capacity cooperation with Ford in Spain was implemented, allowing Lynk & Co to access Volvo's European dealer network, and utilizing manufacturing resources in Malaysia etc. Chery established a European Operations Center in Spain this year, also setting up a research institute, laid out R&D capabilities in France, Germany, and acquired a foreign-owned factory in South Africa, moving manufacturing and operations to the local level.
These three understood the same thing: only when revenue is generated locally and costs are spent locally, can exchange rates not bite you.
Those Falling Behind Are Making Up Ground
Looking at the money-losing ones spread out, the problem is actually clear: they didn't not go overseas, but going overseas hasn't grown to a scale that can handle matters yet.
GAC exported 197,700 vehicles in the first three quarters, up 138.9% YoY. Sounds fierce, but put into its 1.1412 million total sales, it only accounts for about 17%. Moreover, it is still in the stage of laying channels and building outlets. European channels cover 30 countries, over 180 outlets to be built this year, European R&D center won't be enabled until 2027.
Early stage investment is all cost, the fruit isn't ready to be picked yet. Domestic joint venture sector is declining again. GAC Toyota and GAC Honda were once profit cows, now investment income from associates and joint ventures plummeted. Independent sector Aion, Trumpchi still need to spend money to fight for market with new brand Qijun. That overseas sales profit cannot fill the domestic holes.
Its first three quarters combined operating revenue 75.156 billion, up 12.29% YoY. Revenue is still growing, but profit is negative, this is the most glaring place.
Changan actually did quite well going overseas. First three quarters overseas sales 727,000, up 56%, accounting for 43% of total wholesale volume. First half overseas business gross margin 20.13%, domestic only 11.67%. The problem is its overall sales are falling. First three quarters cumulative wholesale 1.6927 million, down 18%, independent brand down 20.24%.
Money earned overseas must fill the holes from domestic sales decline, and withstand raw material price hikes and exchange losses. Q3 exchange loss about 560 million, first three quarters financial expenses 647 million, same period last year was negative 2.066 billion. In and out, profit is ground down to nothing.
Seres is most special. First three quarters sold 283,200 vehicles total, down 16.88% YoY. Among them new energy vehicles 256,500, AITO brand down 17.72%, overseas basically no substantial sales. Its going overseas has only reached certification. AITO full series is promoting EU whole vehicle type certification, only placed full series models at Paris Auto Show in mid-October, goal is to make overseas sales proportion reach one third.
Overseas revenue is still zero, but money that should be spent domestically is not less by a bit. First three quarters R&D expenses 5.689 billion, up 12.4%. Its Q3 1.42 billion net profit, to put it bluntly, not earned from selling cars: single quarter non-current asset disposal gain/loss 2.606 billion, plus book increase from subsidiaries no longer included in consolidation, plus government subsidies. Removing these items, main business is losing money.
Look at the industry big picture. National Bureau of Statistics data shows, first three quarters automotive manufacturing total profit 267.54 billion, down 22.8% YoY, profit margin only 3.33%. September single month is harsher, entire industry profit 14.2 billion, down 68% YoY, profit margin 1.4%, hitting a nearly four-year low.
Meanwhile, exports are soaring. According to CAAM figures, first three quarters China auto exports 8.205 million, up 65.8% YoY. Among them new energy exports 4.006 million, up 1.3 times.
On one side domestic profit is thin to where only a thousand or so remains per car, on the other side overseas is still rising at a two-digit speed. Where the money is, is actually very clear.
But don't think going overseas is too beautiful. On Oct 12, Ministry of Finance and State Taxation Administration issued an announcement. From April 1, 2027, new energy vehicle VAT export refund rate will be lowered from 13% to 9%.
Past some automakers sold overseas cheaper than cost, relied on tax refund to make up loss. This gameplay will become harder to follow. Policy meaning is direct: don't rush volume with low prices anymore, root locally, build brand, do localized operations.
Domestically, the pool will only get more crowded. September new energy passenger car retail penetration rate touched 67.0%, hitting a historical high, yet retail volume down 16.7% YoY. Increment is gone, remaining is mutual destruction in the stock.
So looking back at these two worlds, what's the difference?
It's not who is more hardworking. These eight automakers, each is fighting.
The difference is vision. Who saw through the domestic market ceiling earlier, who was willing to invest real money to build factories, channels, R&D overseas years in advance, who can turn that small price difference of "shipping cars out" into "money earned locally".
BYD, Geely, Chery today's profit, not earned out of thin air this year, seeds planted years ago, just ready to harvest this year. GAC, Changan, Seres today's loss, not all due to mistakes today, more due to not walking that path in previous years, now must take remedial lessons while weathering domestic price wars.
Ma Yue:
At the end of the day, the life and death line of automakers is no longer on the domestic sales list. How many you can sell domestically might only decide how long you can last; whether you can build, sell, and earn money locally, decides how far you can go.
By the time everyone sees a road is easy to walk, this road is already too crowded to fit.
When everyone in the red ocean domestically fights fiercely for thousands of yuan discounts, those who set sail overseas early are already across the ocean, earning money beyond your imagination.
This is the cruelest truth of business: no such thing as industry pressure, only people who can't keep up with trends. The industry downturn you think it is, is just the starting point for others to make big money in a different track.
(This article represents the author's personal views only, does not represent the stance of Mala Che Shi.)
