For a new technology, from R&D to mass production, how long can enterprises actually enjoy a leading advantage?
In the Chinese automotive market, the answer may be getting shorter.
Intelligent configurations that were once scarce can quickly appear on cheaper models; just-established technical advantages might not have time to recover investments before new competitors arrive.
But car manufacturers and suppliers cannot stop innovating. Because if they don't innovate, they might lose orders; if they do, they might not necessarily get sufficient returns.
On October 23, at the 14th Automotive and Environmental Innovation Forum and the 8th Jinji Award "China Solution" Global Awards Ceremony, five executives from Renault, MANN+HUMMEL, Faurecia-Hella, Visteon, and Haiwei discussed the same challenge: Technology innovation is accelerating, how can we turn it into real business value?

Some worry that technology becomes obsolete before launching, others advocate cutting features lacking actual demand yet still insist on investing in innovations that are "unique to us", while others bet on new products initially not viewed favorably. Enterprises not only need to judge which technologies are worth investing in, but also face changes in R&D division of labor and upstream resource competition.
Technology is becoming more mature, but getting higher premiums is becoming harder
Cost advantages of Chinese new energy vehicles in some core technology fields are approaching a new stage.
Renault Group China Chairman and CEO Su Weiming discussed a change at the forum: Looking at fields such as the "Three-Electric System" and Electronic and Electrical Architecture, since 2026, the cost competitiveness of new energy vehicle-related technologies has further strengthened, and costs in related fields are already quite close to conventional fuel vehicles.

Whether technical advantages can truly appeal to consumers is also worth thinking about. Su Weiming observed that in overseas markets such as South America and Singapore, when consumers buy new energy vehicles, they care more about range, price, color, and charging time, rather than specific parameters like battery capacity and motor power.
As for intelligent cockpits, he questioned innovation investments that lack differentiation for some parts. Technical investments continue to increase, but if the final product experience is all the same, it is difficult to form a unique competitive advantage.
J.D. Power's 2026 Chinese Automotive Intelligence Experience Study released in May this year also provided an observation angle: the industry's intelligence innovation index increased by 70 points year-on-year to 658 points, but the function performance index dropped for the first time in four years.
New features continue to increase, but it does not mean that every feature brings a better user experience.

MANN+HUMMEL Global Passenger Car Division President and China Region President Xu Jie frankly admitted at the forum that enterprises have experienced similar challenges. Once a technology is developed, even if it has performance advantages, if it enters the market a year later and cannot realize market application in time, new technology routes and market demands may have appeared, and the original advantages will soon be caught up with or even replaced.
"The speed of bringing innovation to the market now is more important than innovation."
Visteon Group Vice President and Managing Director of Asia Wang Chenglong explained the commercial return of technological innovation from another perspective.
He stated that Visteon will still persist in some "0 to 1" R&D, especially products that can achieve "what others don't have". "Because this can bring better premiums or a dividend period."
Whether technology can form differentiation, when to enter the market, and how long the leading advantage can last all affect the commercial return of innovation.
But not all innovations can calculate returns when the project is initiated. New products that have not yet formed a market are often harder to judge.
Functions to Cut, and NOMI Almost Undervalued
Wang Chenglong stated at the forum regarding R&D trade-offs that Visteon will first judge whether a technology has real demand from the perspective of the vehicle manufacturer and end users. For features that are used very infrequently and lack actual value, if confirmed to be unnecessary after verification, they will decisively stop investment.
But how should real demand be judged?
In August this year, after the typhoon and rainstorm, Gasgoo conducted a survey questionnaire around the car's low-frequency capabilities. Among 390 participants, 46% believed that as long as it is useful in critical moments, it has value even if rarely used normally; another 44% believed that such functions can exist, but should not significantly increase the cost of buying a car.

Regarding willingness to pay, 34% of participants stated they are unwilling to pay extra, and 36% are willing to pay up to 3,000 yuan at most.
Low-frequency use does not necessarily mean a lack of demand; acknowledging a function does not mean willingness to pay the corresponding cost. Especially for safety, emergency, and other capabilities, their value cannot be judged solely by usage frequency; some basic safety capabilities also involve regulatory requirements.
As for new products that have not yet entered the market, whether consumers are willing to pay may be even harder to predict.
Haiwei Founder and CEO Li Linfeng shared the experience of jointly developing NOMI with NIO at the roundtable.
"When Haiwei took on the NIO NOMI project back then, the company's revenue scale was still at the tens of millions of yuan level. Previously, NIO had been searching for partners in the industry for a relatively long time. Thanks to the customer's trust in Haiwei, the Haiwei team eventually completed product development and delivery in 18 months."

But what is more worth paying attention to than the development process is the gap between market performance and initial expectations.
According to Li Linfeng, when the project was launched, the client estimated that the NOMI option rate was only around 30%. However, relying on unique product definition and user interaction experience, NOMI gradually gained market recognition, and the option rate of related products later stayed above 80% for a long time.
Of course, this result has its specific conditions. NIO's brand positioning, user base, and the joint development of both parties may affect the market acceptance of the product. A higher option rate cannot be directly equated with a higher return on investment.
For existing products, enterprises can adjust in time based on actual usage and market feedback; for new products that have not yet formed a market, demand may need to be verified through R&D and product implementation.
If one insists only on certain short-term returns, potential opportunities might be abandoned before being verified. Conversely, if all ideas about future experience are worth long-term investment, even a robust R&D budget cannot withstand the consumption.
The difficulty is not choosing to innovate or stop innovating, but distinguishing whether a project has not yet proven its value or has already proven to lack value.
The former needs to leave space for market verification, while the latter should cut losses in time.
Beyond Single Technologies, What Else Do Suppliers Compete On?
After judging whether a technology is worth investing in, enterprises also need to consider how to improve R&D efficiency.

Wang Chenglong mentioned that in the past, Visteon's R&D in each region was relatively independent, with repeated investments. Nowadays, the company is starting to strengthen global R&D collaboration and regards China as the global innovation incubation center. For example, global R&D of ventilation products is led by the Shanghai team, and related technologies can be further applied to global business after rapid iteration in the Chinese market.
Similar changes also occurred at MANN+HUMMEL. Xu Jie stated that China is growing from one of the world's largest automotive markets to a global source of innovation. MANN+HUMMEL has landed its global new energy technology center in Shanghai, with R&D led by the Chinese team, considering global adaptation synchronously at the product definition stage, combining innovation with speed. Relying on MANN+HUMMEL's business network covering more than 80 branches worldwide, innovation results formed in the Chinese market can achieve global replication and implementation faster, accelerating the transformation from technical innovation to business value.
For R&D results to go global, a corresponding coordination mechanism is also needed. According to Xu Jie's introduction, under the "In China, For the World" strategy, MANN+HUMMEL deeply collaborates Headquarters to Headquarters (H2H), directly connecting with the overseas strategies of Chinese car manufacturers, jointly planning from target market selection, product definition to development rhythm, to reduce resource waste and time delays in intermediate links.
At the same time, Visteon also encourages engineers to establish business thinking, considering how much a product can sell for and whether customers are willing to pay at the R&D stage, not just focusing on the technology itself.
Heiko Lässig, General Manager of Faurecia-Hella Asia-Pacific HQ and Executive Vice President of China Financial Control, mentioned that while the company increased R&D investment, it also reduced costs by continuously evaluating R&D effects and adjusting technology directions in time, without compromising quality.

He classified innovation into foresight R&D, customer-oriented product innovation, as well as manufacturing process and process improvement. Foresight R&D is difficult to determine business returns in advance; customer-oriented innovation must meet actual needs, while process improvement is easier to calculate investment returns.
From global R&D collaboration to investment management of different types of projects, suppliers are trying to improve R&D efficiency. And as vehicle manufacturers continue to expand their in-house R&D scope, Tier 1 also needs to rethink its own technical advantages and business boundaries.
"So how do Tier 1s survive?" Li Linfeng raised this question at the scene.
He believes that a professional Tier 1 can serve multiple vehicle manufacturers simultaneously, splitting R&D costs in specific fields and forming professional advantages. But nowadays, many vehicle manufacturers are promoting full-stack in-house R&D in multiple technical fields. "I found that our OEM customers are all vertically integrating, so we can only try to explore upwards."
Li Linfeng revealed that Haiwei has already started to invest R&D resources in upstream fields such as materials, processes, and equipment.
For Haiwei, whose main business is cockpit display, these investments are not simply cross-border. Display materials, manufacturing processes, and equipment directly affect product performance, yield rate, and mass production costs. If related technologies can be reused in different customer projects, there is a chance to form a stronger competitive barrier.
However, the pressure suppliers face does not only come from vehicle manufacturers. The supply and demand changes in upstream parts are also affecting enterprise R&D investment and mass production arrangements.
Li Linfeng mentioned at the end of the roundtable that since the beginning of this year, PCB, MLCC, and some chips have shown phenomena of price increases and supply fluctuations. He believes that the rapid expansion of AI industry demand is one of the important influencing factors, and judges that the resource siphon effect brought by the AI wave may last for 3-5 years.
This time judgment belongs to Li Linfeng's personal opinion. However, previous research by TrendForce has pointed out that AI demand has driven part of MLCC capacity to transfer to high-end applications, squeezing the supply of some automotive specifications.
There are differences in supply and demand situations of different electronic components, but for some automotive suppliers, the upstream procurement environment they used to be familiar with has begun to change.
Li Linfeng revealed that Haiwei is investing in some upstream enterprises and partners, and has also signed a long-term supply contract with a foreign chip supplier to ensure supply.
From extending R&D upstream to investing in partners and signing long-term supply contracts, these measures of Haiwei involve two aspects: technical capabilities and supply assurance. For suppliers, whether innovation can bring continuous returns depends not only on the technology itself, but also on whether costs can be controlled and delivery can be guaranteed.
Some technologies need to rush time, otherwise the window closes soon; some products need to be verified by the market to discover the value that was initially undervalued; and some basic capabilities, unable to directly create premiums, determine whether products can be mass-produced stably.
In the automotive industry, investing in the wrong innovation may mean resource waste, but giving up too early may also mean missing the next competitive opportunity.
What enterprises really need to judge is which investments should be stopped in time, and which are worth continuing to persist.